Consumer wearables not good enough for Covid-19, say researchers
July 14, 2020
Although it might be tempting to rely on a fitness tracker to catch early signs of Covid-19, researchers at Northwestern University in Illinois caution that consumer wearables are not sophisticated enough to monitor the complicated illness.
The Northwestern team, led by bioelectronics pioneer John Rogers, published a perspective in the Science Advances journal, in which they differentiate between popular consumer electronics and clinical-grade monitoring systems.
Rogers co-authored the perspective with Shuai Xu, a Northwestern Medicine dermatologist, and Hyoyoung Jeong, a postdoctoral fellow in the Rogers lab.
“According to the Journal of the American Medical Association, the three most important early symptoms for Covid-19 are fever, shortness of breath and coughing,” Rogers said. “For a wearable technology, you want to track those key symptoms. A conventional wearable device, such as a fitness tracker, sits on the wrist or finger, not the anatomical location that is most relevant to Covid-19.”
This past spring, the Rogers group and researchers at Shirley Ryan AbilityLab introduced a wearable device and set of data algorithms tailored to catch early signs and symptoms associated with Covid-19 and to monitor patients as the illness progresses. About the size of a postage stamp, the soft, flexible, wireless device sits just below the suprasternal notch, the visible dip at the base of the throat, to monitor respiratory health.
More recently, the team added a wearable, flexible pulse oximeter to pair with the suprasternal-mounted device. This allows physicians to monitor continuously for silent hypoxia, an often asymptomatic feature marked by alarmingly low blood oxygen levels. Adding this feature will help the device and accompanying algorithms give a fuller picture of the disease’s onset, progression and response to treatment.
“The device measures very tiny vibrations on the skin and has an embedded temperature sensor for fever,” Rogers said. “As you cough and breathe, it counts coughs, monitors the intensity of cough and senses laboured breathing. The location on the throat also is close enough to the carotid artery that it can measure mechanical signatures of blood flow, monitoring heart rate.”
Xu added: “This sensor system targets key symptoms for Covid-19, with the goal to identify the infection earlier in patients. It’s a suite of clinical-grade sensors wrapped into one small device. And once it’s placed on the throat, people don’t even realise that it’s there.”
Since launching the device in April, the team has tested it on 52 Covid-19-positive physicians, nurses, rehabilitation specialists and patients at Shirley Ryan AbilityLab and Northwestern Memorial Hospital. The device was tested both in the hospital and in the home.
From these tests, they have collected 3000 hours of data, which will continue to strengthen the device’s algorithms. Eventually, the machine-learning algorithms should become smart enough to distinguish between a Covid-like cough and more benign coughs from allergies, colds or dryness. The team expects to test 500 subjects by the end of the year.
“We are already seeing clear vital sign differences collected by the sensor between patients with Covid-19 and healthy-matched controls,” said Arun Jayaraman, a researcher assistant scientist at Shirley Ryan AbilityLab, who leads the algorithm development. “We’re working together to develop predictive algorithms for detecting the disease earlier.”
Ankit Bharat, chief of thoracic surgery at Northwestern Medicine who performed the first double-lung transplant on a Covid-19 patient in the USA, is actively testing the device on his pulmonary patients. The device wirelessly transmits data to a HIPAA-protected cloud, where automated algorithms produce graphical summaries tailored to facilitate rapid, remote monitoring. This allows Bharat to continue monitoring his patients well after they have been dismissed from the hospital.
“It has provided valuable information about each patient’s respiratory status,” Bharat said. “We hope that, as we gain experience with this device, it will greatly enhance our ability to monitor patients remotely. Under the circumstances of the pandemic, remote monitoring capabilities improve efficiency in medical care while increasing protection to health care workers against the virus.”
To accelerate manufacturing and deployment, Rogers and Xu launched technology start-up Sonica Health, based on intellectual property (IP) jointly developed by Northwestern and the Shirley Ryan AbilityLab. The IP related to this project has been optioned through Northwestern’s Innovation and New Ventures Office. The effort is supported by the Biomedical Advanced Research Deployment Authority (Barda), part of the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Preparedness & Response at the US Department of Health & Human Services.
Sonica Health previously partnered with Barda for technology focused on chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Now the partnership has expanded to focus on early detection of Covid-19 and other respiratory infections in high-risk clinical populations and, with another spinout from QSIB, Sibel Health, to provide the pulse oximetry sensor.
With Barda’s support, Sonica Health and Sibel Health will jointly submit the device and associated algorithms for FDA approval later this month. The overall goal is an FDA-cleared platform that gives an early warning of Covid-19 contraction, helping reduce the transmission of the virus.